BAY CITY, Mich. — Mayor Christopher Girard has vetoed a recently passed city commission resolution that sought to limit local law enforcement’s role in federal immigration enforcement, citing concerns about potential funding losses for Bay City, Bay County, and local nonprofits.
The resolution, introduced by Commissioner Christopher Runberg, was approved by the Bay City Commission in a 5-4 vote. It aimed to prohibit city officials from assisting federal immigration authorities except in cases required by law or court order.
Support my independent journalism by becoming a paid subscriber. I walked awom from the mainstream media to go independent and I can't do this without your help.
Supporters of the Resolution
Proponents argued that the measure would protect local law enforcement from being burdened with federal duties while reducing the risk of legal liability. Commissioner Runberg said the city already followed similar practices, but formalizing the policy would provide greater protection against potential profiling or discrimination. He added that the resolution was about "sending a message of what Bay City stands for," according to coverage by WNEM-TV.
Some residents also supported the measure, citing cases in other communities where local participation in immigration enforcement led to lawsuits. Bay City resident Kayla Harper argued the resolution would ensure that officers focus on local priorities rather than engaging in federal immigration matters, as reported by The Midland Daily News.
Opposition and Financial Concerns
Opponents, including several commissioners and community members, warned that adopting the resolution could result in the loss of state and federal funds. Commission President Stephen Prince expressed concern that Bay City could be seen as subverting immigration enforcement policies, which could put crucial funding sources such as the Community Development Block Grant at risk. He said he was "not willing to do that for a symbolic gesture," The Midland Daily News reported.
Additionally, some residents pointed to House Resolution 19H-1, a proposed measure that could cut funding to municipalities limiting cooperation with federal immigration agencies. Denise Davidson, a Bay City resident, warned that any reduction in funding could impact essential services, according to The Midland Daily News.
Mayor’s Decision
Mayor Girard said he received credible information that adopting the resolution could lead to real financial consequences, not just for Bay City but also for the surrounding county and nonprofits. In a statement, he said the risk was "simply too great" and that the overwhelming majority of residents who contacted him opposed the resolution.
"My responsibility as mayor is to ensure we make choices that protect our residents, our public safety, and our future," Girard said.
Next Steps
The city commission could attempt to override the veto, which would require a two-thirds majority. Given the original 5-4 vote, at least one commissioner would need to change their stance for the override to be successful.
The decision has sparked debate within the community, highlighting the challenge of balancing local governance with broader political and financial implications.
